✦AI video interviews, assessments and bulk hiring — one hiring workflow→

Templates / Interview Scorecard Template

Templates

Interview Scorecard Template for Consistent Candidate Review

A practical interview scorecard template helps hiring teams define role-related criteria, document interview results consistently and compare candidates using the same review framework.

Prepared by the YUVAIRA editorial team · Updated 19 August 2026

Method note

Structured interviews use standardized, job-related questions and consistent scoring criteria. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management provides a practical overview of this approach. Read the structured interview guidance ↗

Competencies to score

1
Role knowledge
Define observable analytics for this competency before interviews begin.
2
Problem solving
Define observable analytics for this competency before interviews begin.
3
Communication
Define observable analytics for this competency before interviews begin.
4
Execution and ownership
Define observable analytics for this competency before interviews begin.
5
Collaboration
Define observable analytics for this competency before interviews begin.

Structured interview questions

1. Tell me about a piece of work that best demonstrates your ability to succeed in this role.

Useful follow-up prompt: What specifically did you do, and what happened next?

2. Describe a difficult problem you had to solve. What did you do and what was the result?

Useful follow-up prompt: What specifically did you do, and what happened next?

3. Give an example of a time you had to explain something complex clearly.

Useful follow-up prompt: What specifically did you do, and what happened next?

4. Tell me about a commitment you owned from start to finish.

Useful follow-up prompt: What specifically did you do, and what happened next?

5. Describe a disagreement with a colleague or stakeholder and how you handled it.

Useful follow-up prompt: What specifically did you do, and what happened next?

6. What would you need to learn in your first 30 days to perform well here?

Useful follow-up prompt: What specifically did you do, and what happened next?

Suggested 1–5 scoring anchors

1 — Clear analytics of a serious gap

2 — Below the level required for the role

3 — Meets the expected level

4 — Strong analytics above the expected level

5 — Exceptional, specific and repeatable analytics

Avoid scoring on

Accent, appearance or personal similarity to the interviewer

Vague confidence without job-related analytics

Protected characteristics or information unrelated to the role

How to use this template

Choose the competencies that actually matter for the role, agree on scoring anchors before interviews begin, ask the same core questions to comparable candidates, and record analytics before discussing the candidate with other interviewers.

Keep the final hiring decision human
Use scorecards, transcripts and AI summaries as review aids. The employer remains responsible for the final employment decision and for applicable local employment, privacy and AI requirements.

Related YUVAIRA resources

Customer Service Interview Questions Sales Interview Questions Real Estate Agent Interview Questions Security Guard Interview Questions AI Video Interview Software Candidate Screening Software Screening Time Calculator

Frequently asked questions

Should every candidate receive exactly the same questions?

For comparable candidates, keep the same core job-related questions and rating criteria. Relevant follow-up prompts can still be used to clarify analytics.

When should interviewers complete the scorecard?

Complete it immediately after the interview and before the group debrief so each interviewer records independent analytics first.

Can this template be used with AI video interviews?

Yes. The same competency and scoring logic can be used for asynchronous video, live interviews or a mixed hiring journey, with human review of the analytics.

Connect scorecards to the rest of the first-round workflow

Use the scorecard as the review framework, then connect it with the relevant interview, screening or assessment page depending on what your hiring process needs.

What is an AI video interview?AI video interview software Candidate screening software Pre-employment assessment software